By Rachel Nielsen
Washington and Beijing played the leading roles
in last week’s downturn on the Russian stock markets, and though
the West delivered more theatrics, the East was widely credited
with the performance of note.
Adding to the drama, there was some evidence of
profit taking after a strong performance to start the new year.
U.S. President Barack Obama’s get-tough approach
on banking, seen by some as a populist play in the aftermath of a
string of political setbacks, pushed down global markets on
Thursday and Friday. But the stage and the mood already were set
for losses Wednesday, when China announced that it was moving to
curb lending and tighten bank controls — a move based on worries
that excess cash could spur inflation.
For the week, the ruble-denominated MICEX Index
was down 2.9 percent, closing at 1410.38, and the
dollar-denominated RTS Index was down 4.5 percent, finishing at
1489.46.
Obama said he wanted to limit the investment
activities and size of banks, which had investors fretting that
profits at U.S. financial corporations could shrink and the amount
of capital available for investments could contract.
“We have to enact common-sense reforms that will
protect American taxpayers and the American economy from future
crises,” Obama told reporters Thursday.
Sberbank dipped 3 percent Friday and 1.8 percent
for the week, while VTB shed 3.9 percent, sending it down 4.7
percent for the week. But analysts said Obama’s plan and U.S.
economic indicators were not going to remain a big concern for
Russia.
“They’re all short-term drivers,” said Kingsmill
Bond, chief strategist at Troika Dialog.
He stressed that oil was still the key driver
for the Russian market. “Right now the oil price is following the
U.S. market,” but Asian growth leading to higher prices for oil is
ultimately the stronger driver for Russian markets, he said.
Spot prices for Urals crude slid 3.6 percent
Friday to close in Moscow trading at $71.19 per barrel, down 6.4
percent on the week.
And if the U.S. economy was big news for the
Russian bourses, China will only get bigger. Some analysts said
they thought that following developments in China was even more
important for accurate stock watching than keeping an eye on the
American markets.
China reported 8.7 percent growth in gross
domestic product for 2009 on Wednesday, but it also announced a
$300 billion reduction in bank lending and other limits on
liquidity.
Liu Mingkang, the Chinese Banking Regulatory
Commission chairman, said the country’s banks were expected to
reduce lending to 7.5 trillion yuan ($1.1 trillion) in 2010, from
an anti-crisis stimulus level of 9.5 trillion yuan in 2009.
He also said steps were taken against banks that
were extending too much credit or making bad loans, adding that
“new leverage and liquidity restrictions would be imposed,” The
Associated Press reported. Earlier this month, major banks in China
were told to increase their reserve ratios, while China’s central
bank increased some interest rates.
The result was investor fear of a reduction in
China’s economic expansion, resulting in less demand for metals,
oil and other raw materials — that is, Russian exports.
All eyes, then, will be on whether the booming
economy actually does slow. With fourth-quarter GDP growth of 10.7
percent, China is poised to become the world’s second-largest
economy later this year. It would unseat Japan, which in December
revised downward its third-quarter growth to 1.3 percent, raising
anew the question of whether the United States or China is more
important for Russia.
Some analysts also saw profit taking as
investors were eager to turn their gains on paper into real
money.
“This negative news from the U.S. and China just
coincided with some investors adjusting their portfolios,” said
Renaissance Capital analyst Ovanes Oganisian. He said the process
had begun in December.
Mark Rubinstein, deputy head of research
at Metropol, also said investors recouping their money was the real
mover. Last week, “profit taking was expected all across the
board,” he said, especially in metals and mining — which did play
out Friday.
Among the biggest losers was Novolipetsk Steel,
which fell 3.4 percent after Goldman Sachs Group changed its
recommendation to “sell,” Bloomberg reported. Severstal escaped the
bank’s broader downgrade on the industry, gaining 1.6 percent after
it was raised to “buy.”
The move to cash out of Russia also appeared to
be a factor behind the latest numbers from fund tracker EPFR
Global. Inflows for Russia equity funds were just $51 million for
the week ending Wednesday, compared with $244.7 million in net
inflows for the previous week.
EPFR data also showed decreases for China equity
funds and commodity sector funds, “as restrictions on Chinese bank
lending raised questions about future demand,” EPFR Global said in
a report Thursday.
This year’s gains in both the MICEX and the RTS
were slimmed over the past week, making room for catch-up starting
Monday. The MICEX had been up 6 percent for the year through Jan.
15, but now is up merely 3 percent for the year, while the RTS
nose-dived from a 7.9 percent gain through Jan. 15, to an increase
of just 3.1 percent.
Whatever the outcome of this week, the past five
trading days made one thing clear: The United States may be making
a lot of noise in Russian markets, but it is China that investors
really should be listening to.